NY Red Bulls vs. New York City FC | More Than Just a Game – It’s a City Divided
The NY Red Bulls against New York City FC – it’s more than just another match on the MLS calendar. It’s a clash of cultures, a battle for bragging rights, and a story of two teams etching their names into the history of New York soccer. But, let’s be honest, it is not quite like the Yankees versus the Mets (yet) but the passion is real.
The Hudson River Derby | A Relatively New Rivalry With Deep Roots

They call it the Hudson River Derby, and while it might not have the century-old history of some of the world’s most famous rivalries, it’s quickly become a must-watch for any New York soccer fan. What fascinates me is how quickly this rivalry has ignited. You see, you’ve got the Red Bulls, a team with roots in the area going all the way back to the Metrostars, playing their games across the river in Harrison, New Jersey. Then there’s NYCFC, the shiny new kids on the block, backed by the City Football Group, playing their home games in the iconic, yet often awkwardly configured, Yankee Stadium. It is a study in contrasts, really. The New York Red Bulls want to show everyone they are the true team of the New York metro area.
Why This Rivalry Matters | More Than Just Wins and Losses
So, why does this game matter beyond the three points in the standings? Well, it’s about identity. This is soccer in a city that is home to just about every nationality on earth , and that cultural melting pot is also present in each club’s supporter base. The Red Bulls, with their longer history, have a dedicated local following. NYCFC, on the other hand, has attracted a broader, more international fanbase – not unlike their parent club, Manchester City. The contrast feeds the fire.
But, it’s also about proving ground. For years, the Red Bulls held the upper hand, dominating the early matchups. But NYCFC has since closed the gap, even winning the MLS Cup in 2021. This is a rivalry defined by constant shifting, the ebb and flow of competition , and the burning desire to be the top dog in the Big Apple.
Key Players to Watch | The Stars Who Define the Derby
Every great rivalry needs its stars, and the Hudson River Derby is no exception. For the Red Bulls, keep an eye on their young homegrown talent. They are always keen to showcase the stars they produce from their academy. NYCFC, meanwhile, often relies on its international imports and seasoned MLS veterans to lead the charge. These are the players who can change the game with a single moment of brilliance – a stunning goal, a pinpoint pass, or a game-saving tackle. In recent years the emergence of players like Omir Fernandez from the Red Bulls and Santiago Rodriguez of NYCFC, have added more fuel to the fire. But, it’s not just the attacking players who make a difference. Goalkeepers, like Carlos Coronel, are pivotal in such high-stakes matches.
The Atmosphere | Experiencing the Derby Firsthand
Trust me; watching the Hudson River Derby on TV is one thing, but experiencing it in person is another level entirely. The energy in the stadium – whether it’s Red Bull Arena or Yankee Stadium – is electric. The supporters’ groups, like the South Ward for the Red Bulls and Third Rail for NYCFC, bring the noise, the passion, and the unwavering support that makes these games so special. It’s a cauldron of chanting, singing, and taunting – all in good fun, of course. This atmosphere can be intimidating. And fans of both clubs usually end up making headlines for all the wrong reasons.
Speaking of the atmosphere, the location definitely plays a role. Red Bull Arena, while a soccer-specific stadium, is located in New Jersey. So there is that. Meanwhile, seeing a soccer match in Yankee Stadium is one of the more surreal experiences in sports. It is just not built for soccer.
Looking Ahead | The Future of the Hudson River Derby
What’s next for this burgeoning rivalry? The beautiful thing is, the story is still being written. As both teams continue to evolve, as new players arrive, and as the stakes get higher, the Hudson River Derby is sure to deliver even more memorable moments in the years to come. The battle for New York soccer supremacy is just getting started.
But, and this is important, it’s also about growing the game. With each thrilling match, with each new fan converted, the Hudson River Derby helps to raise the profile of soccer in a city that already loves the sport. It’s a win-win for everyone involved. It just needs a little more time to cook. The New York soccer scene is more vibrant than ever.
FAQ
Who has won more Hudson River Derby matches?
Historically, the New York Red Bulls have won more matches, but NYCFC has been closing the gap recently.
Where do the Red Bulls play their home games?
The Red Bulls play their home games at Red Bull Arena in Harrison, New Jersey. It is very easy to get to via the PATH train.
Where does New York City FC play their home games?
NYCFC plays their home games at Yankee Stadium in the Bronx, New York.
When is the next Hudson River Derby match?
Check the official MLS schedule for the most up-to-date information on match dates and times. The MLS schedule changes all the time.
How can I get tickets to the game?
Tickets are available through the official team websites or through authorized ticket vendors.
Is the Hudson River Derby a big deal?
Yes! It is one of the most intense and exciting rivalries in Major League Soccer. The game day experience is electric.
So, whether you’re a die-hard supporter or just a casual observer, the Hudson River Derby is a reminder of what makes soccer so special: the passion, the drama, and the unbreakable bond between a team and its city. Now that is something to behold.